A Comparison of Kalman Filter Noise Models for PNT Clocks

Justin Coleman, Bradford Robertson, and Dimitri Mavris

Peer Reviewed

Abstract: The navigation performance of a PNT satellite constellation depends in part on the timing accuracy of the clocks onboard the satellites. Kalman filter models are often used to estimate this timing uncertainty in simulations of Lunar PNT systems. They allow the growth of timing and frequency covariance to be simulated while also incorporating the effects of correcting measurements made from external sources. However, several different Kalman filter models of clock noise exist in the literature which differ in how they approximate flicker frequency noise. Additionally, several of these model include time-dependent noise terms and require care to be implemented correctly. This paper investigates the behavior and implementation of 6 of these models and compares them to a simpler model without flicker noise. When considering just propagation of covariance (i.e. with no measurements), it was found that all 6 models can accurately predict a clock's time deviation, provided their time dependence is correctly accounted for. However, when used in a simple filtering scenario with measurements, each of the models gives somewhat different results depending on the accuracy and frequency of measurements. In general, all of the models exhibit some non-ideal behavior, particularly in cases of very high or low gain. This was examined further by comparing each model's predictions in a nominal Lunar PNT simulation. Here it was found that the different models can result in significantly different error predictions depending on the clock being used. This simulation also demonstrated that an incorrect implementation of the time-dependent can significantly affect results. Overall, these results show that, when using a clock Kalman filter, care must be taken to select a noise model which works accurately for the specific clock and problem under consideration.
Published in: Proceedings of the 39th International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of the Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2026)
September 14 - 18, 2026
Hyatt Regency Grand Cypress
Orlando, Florida
Pages: 950 - 964
Cite this article: Coleman, Justin, Robertson, Bradford, Mavris, Dimitri, "A Comparison of Kalman Filter Noise Models for PNT Clocks," Proceedings of the 39th International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of the Institute of Navigation (ION GNSS+ 2026), Orlando, Florida, September 2026, pp. 950-964. https://doi.org/10.33012/2026.20832
Full Paper:

Sign in to download with your ION membership, download credits or subscription, or buy this article.

Sign In Buy this article: $12 for ION members, $35 for non-members
References:
Show 22 references
  1. Ahn, I. S. (1986). State modeling of clock noises and its application. PhD thesis, Iowa State University, Ames, IA.
  2. Ahn, I. S. and Brown, R. G. (1986). Assessing the validity of suboptimal 2-state clock models. In Proceedings of the 18th Annual PTTI Applications and Planning Meeting, pages 421-436, Washington, DC.
  3. Allan, D. W. and Hellwig, H. (1978). Time deviation and time prediction error for clock specification, characterization, and application. In Proceedings of the Position Location and Navigation Symposium (PLANS), pages 29-36.
  4. Bhamidipati, S., Mina, T., and Gao, G. (2022). Time transfer from gps for designing a smallsat-based lunar navigation satellite system. NAVIGATION: Journal of the Institute of Navigation, 69(3).
  5. Brown, K. R. (1991). The theory of the gps composite clock. In Proceedings of the 4th International Technical Meeting of the Satellite Division of The Institute of Navigation (ION GPS 1991), pages 223-242, Albuquerque, NM.
  6. Brown, R. G. and Hwang, P. Y. C. (1992). Introduction to random signals and applied Kalman filtering. J. Wiley, 2 edition.
  7. Busca, G. and Wang, Q. (2003). Time prediction accuracy for a space clock. Metrologia, 40(3):S265-S269.
  8. Cheung, K.-M., Jun, W. W., Bhamidipati, S., and Carter, P. (2024). Ground-assisted position navigation and timing (pnt) for moon and mars. In 2024 IEEE Aerospace Conference, pages 1-19.
  9. Davis, J. A., Greenhall, C. A., and Stacey, P. W. (2005). A kalman filter clock algorithm for use in the presence of flicker frequency modulation noise. Metrologia, 42(1):488-503.
  10. DoD (2020). Global positioning system standard positioning service performance standard-5th edition.
  11. Durbin, J. and Koopman, S. J. (2012). Time series Analysis by State Space Methods. Oxford University Press, 2 edition.
  12. Gabhart, A. S., Robertson, B. E., and Mavris, D. N. (2026). Alternative Dilution of Precision Measure for Lunar Positioning Systems: Comparison and Sensitivities. Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, pages 1-12.
  13. Galleani, L. (2008). A tutorial on the two-state model of the atomic clock noise. Metrologia, 45(6):S175-S182.
  14. Hartigan, M. and Lightsey, E. G. (2025). Adaptation of one-way radiometric range and range-rate errors to the lunar environment. NAVIGATION: Journal of the Institute of Navigation, 72(3).
  15. Hartigan, M., Lightsey, E. G., and Stewart, S. (2026). Onboard clock modeling for time distribution at the moon. In Proceedings of the ION PTTI Conference.
  16. Konitzer, L., Esantsi, N., and Parker, J. (2022). Navigation Performance Analysis and Trades for the Lunar GNSS Receiver Experiment (LuGRE). In 2022 AAS/AIAA Astrodynamics Specialist Conference, Charlotte, NC.
  17. Krawinkel, T. and Schön, S. (2016). Benefits of receiver clock modeling in code-based gnss navigation. GPS Solutions, 20:687-701.
  18. Riley, W. J. (2008). Handbook of frequency stability analysis. Technical Report NIST Special Publication 1065, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Boulder, CO.
  19. Ryden, G. and Volle, M. (2025). NASA Lunar Communications Relay and Navigation Systems (LCRNS) Reference Constellation 3.
  20. Simon, D. (2006). Optimal State Estimation. Wiley Interscience, 1 edition.
  21. Van Dierendonck, A. J. and Hua, Q. D. (1983). Enhancements to the TTS-502 time transfer system. In Proceedings of the 15th Annual PTTI Applications and Planning Meeting, pages 133-154.
  22. Van Dierendonck, A. J., McGraw, J. B., and Brown, R. G. (1984). Relationship between allan variances and kalman filter parameters. In Proceedings of the 16th Annual PTTI Applications and Planning Meeting, pages 273-293.