Performance Comparison of Deep Integration and Tight Coupling

Matthew Lashley and David M. Bevly

Peer Reviewed

Abstract: This paper presents a comparative analysis of tight coupling and deep integration. Three deeply integrated and two tightly coupled architectures are analyzed. The analysis of the different architectures is performed using the same grade inertial measurement units, satellite constellations, and GPS signal processing techniques (i.e., identical discriminators, coherent integration times, and C/N0 ratio estimators). Three aspects of the architectures are studied. The first is the general performance improvement offered by deep integration over tight coupling. The second is the effect of using a federated filtering architecture instead of using a single, centralized filter. The third aspect analyzed is the performance of the algorithms when operated with and without vector tracking. The analysis shows that the architectures with vector tracking perform virtually identically. The algorithms using scalar tracking loops perform worse in comparison. However, all the architectures yield comparable performance when the C/N0 ratio is below 29 dB-Hz.
Published in: NAVIGATION: Journal of the Institute of Navigation, Volume 60, Number 3
Pages: 159 - 178
Cite this article: Export Citation
Full Paper: ION Members/Non-Members: 1 Download Credit
Sign In